Thursday, September 1, 2011

#638 - Cubs/Jim Marshall


Card fact: This is the final team card in the set. I'll commemorate it by noting which color combinations were used with each team:

1. Orange-yellow (8): Yankees, Braves, Reds, Rangers, Twins, Angels, Royals, Phillies
2. Brown-orange (6): Cubs, A's, Astros, Dodgers, Giants, Orioles
3. Tan-light blue (6): Mets, Pirates, White Sox, Cardinals, Red Sox, Padres
4. Brown-tan (4): Brewers, Indians, Expos, Tigers

What I thought about this card then: Zzzzzzzzzzz. Team card.

What I think about this card now: Well, first, it's probably the most out-of-focus, far-away team photo in the whole set, which might explain why the Cubs stuck with floating head team cards for most of the '70s and early '80s.

Secondly, I still don't know why the Cubs went with the team pose and the White Sox the floating heads in '75 when it was flip-flopped all the other years.

Other stuff: The Cubs finished dead last in 1974, their first last-place finish since 1966. Jim Marshall replaced Whitey Lockman as manager in the middle of the season. Marshall would last two more sub-.500 seasons before Herman Franks took over for the 1977 season.


Back facts: Darold Knowles, Bob Locker and Manny Trillo are all listed on the Cubs checklist although none played for the team in '74. All are airbrushed into Cubs caps.

Other blog stuff: One last opportunity to see how well Topps represented a team from the 1974 season. Let's see how many Cubs from '74 were in the Topps set.

The Cubs used 38 players in 1974, including a bunch of guys I never knew (Herb Hutson? Ron Dunn?). Topps featured 26 of those players, including Billy Williams as an airbrushed Athletic, and Horacio Pina as an airbrushed Angel.

My quest to see if Topps left out anyone significant is rather pointless with the Cubs, because it's the Cubs! Come on! The guy with the most at-bats who didn't get a card is Dave Rosello. He hit .203 in 148 at-bats. Rob Sperring also didn't get a card. He hit .206 in 107 at-bats.

So Topps kindly represented 68.42% of the '74 Cubs in the '75 set.

This is where they rank with the other teams:

1. Twins 81.25% of players featured
2. Tigers 78.37%
3. Orioles 78.13%
4. Braves 77.78%
5. Reds 77.14%
6. A's 75.0%
7. Dodgers 74.29%
7. Astros 74.29%
9. Giants 71.43%
10. Indians 71.11%
11. Royals 70.59%
12. Yankees 70.45%
13. Red Sox 70.27%
14. Angels 68.89%

15. Cubs 68.42%
16. Expos 68.29%
17. Brewers 66.67%
18. Rangers 65.79%
19. Cardinals 65.12%
20. White Sox 65.0%
21. Phillies 62.5%
22. Mets 62.16%
23. Pirates 61.5%

24. Padres 55.8%

That's all of them! The Twins are better represented in the set than any other team. How about that?

And my real mission was to see if anyone major was left out of the set as has been the case in some other Topps sets. I wasn't able to find anyone significant, though, in the '75 set.

4 comments:

Play at the Plate said...

Whoo hoo! The Rangers made the top 18!!

Kevin said...

Fun fact (to me, anyway): Jim Marshall is one of 5 ex-Oriole players to manage the Cubs. There's Marshall, Bob Kennedy, Whitey Lockman, Don Baylor, and Lou Piniella. One-time O's coaches Jim Frey and Tom Trebelhorn and former manager Joe Altobelli have also skippered on the North side.

Jim said...

This was the last card my Dad and I needed to complete our 1975 Topps set. The old pocket-sized price guide I had listed card #638 as Jim Marshall so we spent more than one baseball card show walking from dealer to dealer in search of the "1975 Topps Jim Marshall card."

It never dawned on us to look for card #638 - we just knew we needed the Jim Marshall card. Finally, after a few unsuccessful card shows, we wised up and told a dealer we needed "card #638" from the 1975 Topps set.

"Oh, you need the Cubs team card," the dealer responded. My Dad and I smiled at one another as we never once thought to look for Jim Marshall on a team card. I remember staring at the card the whole car ride home, amazed at the realization that we had just completed the 1975 Topps set.

night owl said...

Great story, Jim.

I was just mentioning on another blog that when I was writing this, I wondered if there was a card out there of Jim Marshall the player. There was -- back in the early '60s, not like the mid-70s like you thought.